| 1959 | L. E. Watson * | 1977 | Marvin Knopp | 1995 | Vern Gannon * | 2013 | Richard Garvin |
| 1960 | Charles Macy * | 1978 | L. H. “Bing” Carter * | 1996 | Lonny McCurdy | 2014 | Megan McCurdy Niedens |
| 1961 | W. O. Harris * | 1979 | Ernest Persinger * | 1997 | John Omli * | 2015 | Bill Eberhardt |
| 1962 | Carson Hansen * | 1980 | Robert E. Shank * | 1998 | Vern Koch | 2016 | Robert Haley |
| 1963 | Paul Hurst * | 1981 | Earl M. Brown * | 1999 | Charles Beatty * | 2017 | Aaron Traffas |
| 1964 | Fred Sherlock * | 1982 | Milton Anderson * | 2000 | Buddy Griffin | 2018 | Kevin Borger |
| 1965 | C. W. “Bill” Crites * | 1983 | Floyd Gehring * | 2001 | Mike Gatlin | 2019 | Jeff Ruckert |
| 1966 | Marvin Meyers * | 1984 | Larry Theurer | 2002 | Jerry Pitney * | 2020 | Lenny Mullin |
| 1967 | Lawrence Welter * | 1985 | Ron Gingerich | 2003 | John Shoemaker * | 2021 | Thomas Linsday |
| 1968 | Wilson Hawk * | 1986 | Bob Thummel | 2004 | Don Hamit | 2022 | Braden McCurdy |
| 1969 | Joe E. Gingerich * | 1987 | Bob Bloomer * | 2005 | Garry Hostetler * | 2023 | Titus Yutzey |
| 1970 | John G. Collins * | 1988 | Tom Lindsay | 2006 | Rick Brock | ||
| 1971 | R. M. Brewer * | 1989 | Gary Potter * | 2007 | Ron Shivers * | ||
| 1972 | Roy Wood * | 1990 | Leland Boesker | 2008 | Bob McBride | ||
| 1973 | Rex B. Newcom | 1991 | Robert Wilson * | 2009 | Dave Webb |
* Deceased